How to Measure Innovation ROI & Why It's Important

According to a McKinsey report, 84% of executives say innovation is critical to growth, yet only 6% are satisfied with their innovation performance.

The good news is that when measured effectively, innovation can drive significant returns.

In this article, you will learn how to measure innovation ROI and why it’s essential for making smarter, bolder business decisions. 

Let’s get started!

Why Disruptive Innovation Matters and What It Means For ROI

Disruptive innovation can redefine entire industries by changing how value is delivered and how we think about return on investment (ROI).

Companies that fail to innovate risk losing relevance, while those that embrace disruption often unlock entirely new paths to growth.

Disruptive innovation helps you:

• Spot the next big opportunity – Investing in innovation uncovers emerging markets early and creates a competitive edge, just like Tesla did with electric vehicles.
• Stay agile – Innovation enables quick adaptation to shifting customer expectations and evolving technology.
• Build a culture of experimentation – Encouraging bold thinking and testing new ideas fuels continuous learning and breakthrough growth.

However, this type of innovation usually doesn’t deliver immediate financial returns and requires an approach to calculating ROI that takes uncertainty and learning into account.

For example, Blockbuster dismissed the potential of streaming, an oversight that allowed Netflix to dominate the market.

Similarly, Nokia underestimated the smartphone revolution sparked by Apple and lost market leadership.

Today, these companies are reminders of what happens when businesses resist innovation.

Why Innovation Projects Often Fall Short on ROI

Despite all the excitement around innovation, many companies struggle to turn great ideas into actual financial returns. Here are some common reasons why:

• Overemphasis on single projects – Treating each innovation effort like a high-stakes moonshot adds unnecessary pressure.
  A better strategy is to manage innovation as a portfolio, spreading risk across several initiatives.
• Poor alignment with corporate strategy – Chasing trendy ideas without linking them to business goals often leads to wasted effort.
  

  In fact, almost 50% of failed innovations are misaligned with core business goals.

• Underinvesting in discovery – Skipping early steps like customer interviews or MVP testing can backfire. Without early feedback, teams risk building solutions no one wants.
• Mismatch of metrics – Applying traditional ROI models to early-stage innovation creates unrealistic expectations. These projects need more flexible metrics that reflect uncertainty and iteration.

6 Steps to Measure Innovation ROI

Measuring innovation ROI often perplexes leaders because classic formulas rely on predictability. Innovation, on the other hand, involves high levels of uncertainty.

Let’s break it down into 6 simple steps:

Step 1: Define Innovation Objectives

Before diving into the numbers, take a step back and define the main goal of each innovation initiative. Here are a few common goals to consider:

• Driving revenue growth – Are you targeting a new customer segment? Launching a new product that could expand your market?
  If so, your focus might be on increasing sales or tapping into unmet demand.
• Boosting efficiency – Maybe the aim is to streamline workflows or cut down on operational costs. In this case, your ROI might center around time saved, reduced expenses, or improved productivity.
• Expanding into new markets – Some initiatives involve entering new regions or industries. Success here could be measured by increased brand awareness, acquiring new leads, or establishing strategic partnerships.

Step 2: Set Clear KPIs

Your innovation KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) transform broad objectives into concrete targets. Each type of innovation objective should have corresponding KPIs that enable tracking over time.

• For revenue-oriented innovations – Track the number of paying users, monthly recurring revenue (MRR), average order value (AOV), or the conversion rate from pilot users to paid subscriptions.
• For efficiency-focused innovations – Measure time saved in production cycles, error rate reduction, or improvement in employee productivity.
• For market expansion – Monitor metrics such as partnership sign-ups, distribution agreements secured, brand awareness (via surveys), or net promoter score (NPS) in new regions.

💡Pro Tip

With the rready platform, you can track innovation activity across your organization in real time. The Analytics Dashboard gives you a clear, actionable view of key metrics to support reporting, strategy, and stakeholder engagement. Here is what you can expect:

• See how many projects are in each phase of development, with filters for total counts or specific organizational units.
• Track user sign-ups over time to understand engagement trends and measure program reach across different units.
• Monitor badge achievements to see how users progress and engage with the platform’s recognition system.
• Set custom time ranges to analyze platform activity and idea submissions during specific periods.
• Manually enter values like estimated revenue and success probability to generate approximate ROI insights using a funnel-based model.

Step 3: Establish a Baseline

To measure ROI accurately, you must know where you’re starting from. 

It serves as your baseline, helping you distinguish which gains are driven by innovation and which result from normal growth or seasonal trends.

To set a solid baseline:

• Capture the current state – Record data like production times, sales volumes, or profit margins.
• Watch for outside influences – Seasonal trends or economic shifts can throw off your numbers. If your business has ups and downs throughout the year, use a rolling average to smooth things out.
• Get user feedback – If your innovation affects the customer experience, gather baseline data through surveys or interviews. Track user satisfaction or brand perception to measure how they change over time.

Step 4: Track Inputs, Outputs, and Outcomes

Tracking your innovation efforts isn’t just about what you do. It’s about what you invest, what you create, and what results from it.

Break it down into inputs, outputs, and outcomes to clearly measure progress and impact.

Inputs

These are the resources you're putting into the process. Think about everything it takes to get ideas off the ground, like:

• budget
• employee time
• consulting fees
• software tools

This will help you distinguish between direct costs (like prototyping tools or software licenses) and indirect costs (such as overhead from team collaboration or shifts in operational focus).

Outputs

Outputs are the results generated during the innovation process:

• prototypes
• mock-ups
• beta versions
• pilot programs
• number of ideas generated.

However, it's not just about quantity. A stack of prototypes doesn’t mean much unless they move you closer to solving real problems.

💡Pro Tip

Innovation thrives when employees can actively engage with each other’s ideas. With rready’s innovation solutions, everyone in the organization can contribute to innovation and collaborate in real-time. This not only increases transparency but also helps surface the most promising ideas based on collective input, such as engagement levels, feasibility, and alignment with business goals.

AI can further streamline this process by instantly connecting ideas with relevant experts, making it easier to develop high-potential concepts with the right people involved from the start.

Outcomes

Outcomes reflect the ultimate business impact. This could mean:

• increased revenue
• reduced costs
• improved customer retention
• better brand perception.

Keep in mind that outcomes can evolve with the maturity of the project.

In the early stages, the focus may be on validated learning or user feedback. Later on, it shifts toward more tangible results, like net profit, market share, or customer growth.

Step 5: Use the ROI Formula Where Applicable

Once an innovation project has progressed enough to show measurable financial results, you can use the classic Return on Investment (ROI) formula. But keep in mind that “gains” can take many forms that aren’t immediately quantifiable.

To apply the ROI formula:

• Calculate the gains – Figure out the financial benefit. For a new product, this could be net revenue, and for a process improvement, it might be cost savings or increased productivity converted into dollars.
• Add up the costs – Include everything: design, development, testing, marketing, and ongoing operations.
• Calculate ROI – Subtract the total cost from the total gain, then divide by the total cost.

💡Tip

Some innovations take years to pay off. In those cases, you may want to use Net Present Value (NPV) or Internal Rate of Return (IRR) instead.

If you’re still in the pilot phase, you might not see actual gains yet, but projected revenue or cost savings can serve as early indicators.

In its early years, Amazon consistently reported losses, including the first seven years of operation, accumulating debts of $2 billion by 2000.

However, that was not a sign the project had failed. It reflected a long-term investment strategy that ultimately led to significant success.

Step 6: Track Progress Over Time

A new process might initially show only small improvements, but as it is adopted across departments, the benefits can grow drastically.

Similarly, a new product might start slowly but gain momentum as your brand and reputation grow.

To track your progress:

• Check-in regularly – Set up quarterly or biannual reviews to track key metrics and hold “learning sessions” to spot trends.
• Measure against the starting point – Show how things have changed since launch to highlight progress and build stakeholder confidence.
• Update your goals – As you learn more about users, production, or market shifts, adjust your KPIs to reflect new insights.
• Listen beyond the numbers – Use surveys, interviews, and team reflections to uncover changes in user behavior or company culture that data alone might miss.

Challenges in Measuring Innovation ROI

Evaluating the return on innovation isn’t as straightforward as tracking sales or expenses. That’s because innovation involves many overlapping factors that make it hard to draw clear conclusions.

Let’s explore some key challenges:

• Delayed payoffs – The benefits of innovation often take months or even years to show. This time lag makes it difficult to rely on short-term metrics to gauge success.
• Intangible outcomes – Many valuable outcomes, like stronger brand reputation, increased customer loyalty, or better employee engagement, don’t show up on a balance sheet and can’t be easily quantified.
• High uncertainty and risk – Innovation is inherently unpredictable. Because new ideas don’t always follow a clear path, estimating future returns accurately is nearly impossible.
• Overlapping business changes – Innovations rarely happen in a vacuum. Changes in marketing, operations, or overall strategy often happen simultaneously, making it hard to isolate and measure the specific impact of a single innovation initiative.

How Can rready Help You Make Innovation Count?

rready provides flexible, AI-native innovation management solutions to help organizations seamlessly generate, capture, refine, and implement ideas from concept to execution.

Our tailored approach streamlines the ideation process, enhances collaboration, and drives engagement, empowering employees with the tools and support they need to turn ideas into impactful outcomes.

Our offerings include:

• rready Idea Management,
• KICKBOX Intrapreneurship, and
• rready Innovation Management.

To make our solutions even more powerful, rready integrates smart AI features that boost ideation, collaboration, and decision-making:

• Language-agnostic search & content translation – Search in your preferred language as our AI automatically translates content, making it easy for everyone to understand and contribute.
• AI Agents –These intelligent agents deliver personalized support, generate context-aware tasks, and provide smart suggestions in real time.
  By pre-filling fields, offering relevant feedback, and adapting seamlessly to company-specific workflows, AI agents streamline operations and drive a more efficient, innovative work environment.
• Similarity Search – Instantly spot and explore similar ideas to avoid duplication and encourage meaningful collaboration.
• AI-Generated Images – Bring ideas to life visually with automatically generated images that enhance each idea’s profile.
• Inspire Feature – Admins can invite multiple users to join a campaign and provide them with a set of pre-generated ideas tailored to the company, the challenge, and each user's skills.

This lowers the barrier to participation and helps spark inspiration.

rready Idea Management

Managing ideas efficiently can save your company time, money, and valuable resources. Without a clear system, missed opportunities and wasted efforts can cost millions. That’s where we come in.

Our idea management platform gives you a structured, customizable system for collecting, evaluating, and implementing ideas, ensuring only the most promising ideas surface.

With our intuitive tools, your team can:

• Submit ideas with detailed descriptions.
• Upload images or generate visuals using AI.
• Categorize ideas by topic for easy discovery.
• Add videos, files, links, tags, and feedback for a complete submission.
• Use AI-powered tools to refine and enhance their ideas for clarity and impact.

KICKBOX Intrapreneurship

The KICKBOX Intrapreneurship Program provides your employees with tools, knowledge, and structure to explore innovative ideas and turn them into actionable outcomes.

It encourages a culture of innovation, empowering team members to take initiative and share their creative solutions.

At the heart of the program is the KICKBOOK, a practical, step-by-step guide filled with tips, tools, and real-world insights. It supports employees at every stage, helping them transform ideas into real, impactful outcomes.

rready Innovation Management

Our Innovation Management solution combines Idea Management and KICKBOX Intrapreneurship to help you manage your entire innovation portfolio, from the initial idea to full implementation.

But it’s more than just collecting ideas. Here’s how our platform empowers your innovation process:

• Simplifies login and security with Single Sign-On (SSO) and Active Directory integration.
• Lets you launch targeted campaigns to gather ideas that align with your business goals.
• Enables you to set submission time frames so employees can contribute when their input is most valuable.
• Allows bulk invitations to engage employees in challenges that match their skills and company priorities.
• Delivers personalized idea recommendations straight to inboxes through AI-powered suggestions.

Book a demo today and discover how rready can help your team turn ideas into measurable business impact!

Keep Learning

20 Innovation KPIs to Measure Success [+Examples]

HYPE Innovation vs. Jira - Which One Is Better for You?

The 7 Best Idea Management Software Tools to Consider in 2025